Cut First, Bulk First—Or Both?

People often ask the same question: Should I lose fat first or build muscle first—or try to do both? It’s a fair question, and one that doesn’t have a one-size-fits-all answer. Both goals are valuable, but sequencing or balancing them the right way makes the difference between steady progress and months of frustration.

The idea of “body recomposition”—losing fat while building muscle—gets tossed around a lot. And yes, it’s possible. Beginners, people returning after a long layoff, or those with higher body fat levels often see fat drop while muscle increases. The stimulus is novel, the body is responsive, and the margin for improvement is wide.

For more seasoned lifters, though, it gets trickier. Building muscle generally requires a calorie surplus, while losing fat requires a deficit. Trying to chase both aggressively at the same time usually leads to stalled results, low energy, or poor recovery. You can walk both paths slowly, or you can focus on one and move faster.

Both approaches work, but the right choice depends on the person.

Cutting first works well for those carrying more body fat. A mild calorie deficit—paired with high protein and consistent training—can shed fat while preserving muscle. The individual will see a leaner physique quickly, which often builds motivation. The key here is to keep the deficit moderate, not extreme, and to emphasize protein intake around 1.8–2.0 g/kg of body weight.

Building first makes sense for leaner individuals who want long-term progress. Muscle is metabolically active tissue—it burns energy even at rest. Spending a phase in a slight calorie surplus (+300–500 calories per day), with carbs fueling workouts and recovery, lets clients add muscle that later makes fat loss easier and more effective. The scale might creep up, but the added muscle provides shape, strength, and resilience.

Both approaches require patience. What doesn’t work well is trying to cut hard while simultaneously expecting dramatic muscle gains—those goals often cancel each other out.

Chasing both goals without prioritizing often results in diluted effort: not enough calories to truly build, not enough focus to truly cut. Energy suffers, training intensity drops, and progress slows. Coaches who push clients to choose a main goal for a block of time—fat loss or muscle gain—see better adherence and better results.

That doesn’t mean the “other” goal gets ignored. In a cut phase, training still signals the body to keep muscle. In a build phase, smart nutrition choices keep fat gain minimal. But clarity of focus allows the body to adapt instead of sending it mixed signals.

Think of it as choosing a lens to look through for a few months.

• In a cut phase, calories are dialed just below maintenance. The focus is on steady fat loss while holding strength. Protein is high, recovery is prioritized, and the goal is to keep muscle while shedding fat.

• In a build phase, calories are gently pushed above maintenance. Protein remains high, but carbs become more prominent to fuel higher-volume training and recovery. The goal is to progressively overload and add lean mass while keeping fat gain in check.

• In a recomposition phase, calories hover near maintenance, protein intake is high, and training is steady. This is most effective for beginners or those returning after a break, where even small surpluses or deficits can create noticeable shifts in body composition.

Each phase has its place. The trick is executing the right phase at the right time.

Yes, you can build muscle and lose fat at the same time, but it’s not the most efficient path for everyone. Most individuals see faster progress when they focus on one goal for a block of time: cut if you’re carrying more fat, build if you’re already relatively lean. Beginners can often have it both ways, but experienced lifters benefit from clear goal phases.

Whichever route is chosen, the principles remain constant: eat for the goal, train hard and progressively, and recover fully. Fat loss without strength isn’t sustainable. Muscle gain without good nutrition just leads to fatigue. Prioritize smartly, commit to the phase, and the results stack up over time.

1. Barakat C. (2020). Body recomposition: Building muscle while losing fat. NSCA Sports Journal.

2. Business Insider Nutrition Clinic. (2025). How to build muscle and lose fat: two strategies.

3. Ellis K. (2025). Prioritize muscle building first to spark fat loss. Men’s Health.

4. Walsh J. (2025). 70/30 rule: 70% nutrition, 30% training for results. New York Post.

5. Verywell Health. (2025). Can you build muscle while in a calorie deficit?